Many assume replacing an appliance is easier than repairing it. However, that’s not always the most cost-effective or efficient solution. Let’s explore the pros and cons.
Pros of Replacing an Appliance
✅ Factory Warranty: A new appliance comes with a one-year factory warranty, offering peace of mind. However, if it breaks within the first year, you might have a lemon.
✅ Newer Models: You get the latest features, better energy efficiency, and sometimes improved performance.
✅ Fewer Repairs: If your old appliance had recurring issues, a new one could save you from constant repairs.
Cons of Replacing an Appliance
🔴 Warranty Repairs Can Be a Hassle: If your new appliance fails under warranty, the factory assigns a local authorized repair service. Many of these technicians lack factory training. Since warranty work pays 50-70% less than cash jobs, they may not prioritize your repair. Customers often wait weeks, especially during busy seasons.
🔴 Higher Costs Than Expected: The price tag of a new appliance doesn’t include taxes, shipping, haul-away fees, and installation. A $700 appliance can quickly turn into a $900+ expense. If you rejected a $400 repair thinking it was too expensive, you may end up paying much more.
🔴 Lower Quality: Appliances today don’t last as long as those made 10-15 years ago. Customers often tell us their 40-year-old GE fridge still runs, while their 3-year-old Samsung or LG refrigerator has already failed.
🔴 Installation Challenges: Built-in appliances, double ovens, and cooktops often require cabinet modifications, adding thousands to the total cost.
Is an Extended Warranty Worth It?
Many stores offer extended warranties. Paying an extra $100 to cover your appliance for up to five years sounds great, but reality is different.
🔸 Higher Costs: Most extended warranties cost between $240-$340—not just $100.
🔸 Hidden Fees: Many warranty companies charge a $60-$70 diagnostic fee, even if they approve the repair.
🔸 Limited Coverage: Some claims get denied. They may refuse to replace a washer pump, saying it was used commercially. They might also reject an ice maker repair, blaming user damage, or refuse to replace a dryer heating element due to poor vent maintenance.
🔸 Delays in Repairs: Even when approved, warranty repairs take time. Parts need authorization, and scheduling can be slow.
When Does Repair Make More Sense?
If your appliance is in decent condition and the repair cost is less than half of a new one, repairing is usually the better choice.
We’ve saved customers thousands by repairing double ovens and control boards, even when parts were discontinued. By sending control boards to certified repair shops, we fixed ovens for $700-$900. Compare that to replacing one for $2,500+ plus $1,500 in cabinet adjustments.
Final Advice on Replacing an Appliance vs. Repairing
Before rejecting a repair quote, crunch the numbers and consider all costs. If you’re in Atlanta, Buckhead, Alpharetta, Roswell, or Marietta, call us for an expert assessment! 📞 (404)903-1453 or Book 24/7 Online